Movies The Phantom Menace VS. Attack Of The Clones VS. Revenge Of The Sith

[PanSimpson]

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace (1999):

Star Wars Episode II: Attack Of The Clones (2002):

Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith (2005):

Which of George Lucas' three Star Wars Prequels was the best movie of the trilogy in your opinion or the LEAST BAD (if your a hater of Episodes I-III)?

My ranking of Episodes I-III:

1. Attack Of The Clones
2. Revenge Of The Sith
3. The Phantom Menace

 

[Super Kami Guru]

I'm voting for Episode 1, but only because of pod racing...otherwise, it's like picking the best of the venereal diseases...

 

[PanSimpson]

I'm voting for Episode 1, but only because of pod racing...otherwise, it's like picking the best of the venereal diseases...

I LOVED The Phantom Menace as a kid, it's the Star Wars movie along with the original 1977 film that got me into Star Wars as a kid and I was one of Episode I's BIGGEST DEFENDERS for a LONG TIME.........but I guess you can say after smarting up and the more I really thought about it....I REALLY realized I was REALLY BLINDED by NOSTALGIA GLASSES and I realized my love for the movie was EXTREMELY SUPERFICIAL and that the movie WASN'T ALL THAT....

Episode II just APPEALS SO MUCH MORE to MY TASTES and it's just a much better Star Wars movie and overall Star Wars movie all-round.

As for Revenge Of The Sith, I still like it a lot, but it's not as good as I thought it was back in 2005 and the flaws of the movie have become more and more obvious with time, but it's NOWHERE NEAR AS BAD as Episode I.

 

[Super Kami Guru]

What bugs me about the prequels is that they built up Darth Maul to be this amazing Sith that was going to be a proper villain to the Jedi...and then he's dead in one movie having done very little except kill Qui-Gon Jinn...disappointing...

 

[New York Yankees Fan]

1. Revenge Of The Sith
2. The Phantom Menace
3. Attack Of The Clones

 

[New York Yankees Fan]

Eh, who am I kidding...Attack Of The Clones is #1 BY FAR:

1. Attack Of The Clones
2. The Phantom Menace
3. Revenge Of The Sith

 

[Kid Goku]

Revenge of the sith is my favourite Starwars movie mostly because of the Epic Lightsaber battles and anakin vs Obiwan specifically!
To my defense the german Prequels have much better Voice acting!

 

[India Actual]

What bugs me about the prequels is that they built up Darth Maul to be this amazing Sith that was going to be a proper villain to the Jedi...and then he's dead in one movie having done very little except kill Qui-Gon Jinn...disappointing...

*whispers* He's not dead after that.

 

[Super Kami Guru]

*whispers* He's not dead after that.

I know, but in the films he is, he's just...a waste.

 

[Mustafar Reginald]

I've only seen Revenge of the Sith so that. I recall liking the movie, a bunch of children died which is always a plus and the final fight was really cool, had a really cool setting too. I can't quite recall what the planet was called though, it's on the of tip of my avatar. OH, I remember now, Reginald! Such a hot planet, Reginald definitely my favourite location in Star Wars.

 

[Cunning Slytherin]

The Phantom Menace. It has the best soundtrack of the trilogy and is carried by Liam Nelson’s performance as Qui-Gon Jinn, the Pod Race, Darth Maul and the final lightsaber duel.

 

[Giga Hertz]

Sith is the best Star Wars movie full stop.